Black Box, White Box and Gray Box Testing

 
Black Box testing refers to the technique of testing a system with no knowledge of the internals of the system. Black Box testers do not have access to the source code and are oblivious of the system architecture. A Black Box tester typically interacts with a system through a user interface by providing inputs and examining outputs without knowing where and how the inputs were operated upon. In Black Box testing, target software is exercised over a range of inputs and the outputs are observed for correctness.

Advantages

a. Efficient Testing — Well suited and efficient for large code segments or units. 

b. Unbiased Testing — clearly separates user's perspective from developer's perspective through separation of QA and Development responsibilities. 

c. Non intrusive — code access not required. 

d. Easy to execute — can be scaled to large number of moderately skilled testers with no knowledge of implementation, programming language, operating systems or networks. 

Disadvantages

a. Localized Testing — Limited code path coverage since only a limited number of test inputs are actually tested. 

b. Inefficient Test Authoring — without implementation information, exhaustive input coverage would take forever and would require tremendous resources. 

c. Blind Coverage — cannot control targeting code segments or paths which may be more error prone than others.  



White Box Testing refers to the technique of testing a system with knowledge of the internals of the system. White Box testers have access to the source code and are aware of the system architecture. A White Box tester typically analyzes source code, derives test cases from knowledge about the source code, and finally targets specific code paths to achieve a certain level of code coverage. A White Box tester with access to details about both operations can readily craft efficient test cases that exercise boundary conditions.

Advantages

a. Increased Effectiveness — Crosschecking design decisions and assumptions against source code may outline a robust design, but the implementation may not align with the design intent. 

b. Full Code Pathway Capable — all the possible code pathways can be tested including error handling, resource dependencies, and additional internal code logic/flow. 

c. Early Defect Identification — Analyzing source code and developing tests based on the implementation details enables testers to find programming errors quickly. 

d. Reveal Hidden Code Flaws — access to source code improves understanding and uncovering unintended hidden behavior of program modules.

Disadvantages

a. Difficult To Scale — requires intimate knowledge of target system, testing tools and coding languages, and modeling. It suffers for scalability of skilled and expert testers. 

b. Difficult to Maintain — requires specialized tools such as source code analyzers, debuggers, and fault injectors. 

c. Cultural Stress — the demarcation between developer and testers starts to blur which may become a cultural stress.

d. Highly Intrusive — requires code modification has been done using interactive debuggers, or by actually changing the source code. This may be adequate for small programs; however, it does not scale well to larger applications. Not useful for networked or distributed systems. 


Difference between Black Box and White Box Testing

1. Synonyms for black-box include: behavioral, functional, opaque-box, and closed-box. 

2. Synonyms for white-box include: structural, glass-box and clear-box.

3. Generally black box testing will begin early in the software development i.e. in requirement gathering phase itself. But for white box testing approach one has to wait for the designing has to complete.

4. We can use black testing strategy almost any size either it may be small or large. But white box testing will be effective only for small lines of codes or piece of codes.

5. In white box testing we can not test Performance of the application. But in Black box testing we can do it.



Gray Box Testing refers to the technique of testing a system with limited knowledge of the internals of the system. Gray Box testers have access to detailed design documents with information beyond requirement documents. Gray Box tests are generated based on information such as state-based models or architecture diagrams of the target system.

Advantages

a. Offers Combined Benefits — Leverage strengths of both Black Box and White Box testing wherever possible. 

b. Non Intrusive — Gray Box does not rely on access to source code or binaries. Instead, based on interface definition, functional specifications, and application architecture. 

c. Intelligent Test Authoring — Based on the limited information available, a Gray Box tester can author intelligent test scenarios, especially around data type handling, communication protocols and exception handling. 

d. Unbiased Testing — The demarcation between testers and developer is still maintained. The handoff is only around interface definitions and documentation without access to source code or binaries. 

Disadvantages

a. Partial Code Coverage — Since the source code or binaries are not available, the ability to traverse code paths is still limited by the tests deduced through available information. The coverage depends on the tester authoring skills. 

b. Defect Identification — Inherent to distributed application is the difficulty associated in defect identification. Gray Box testing is still at the mercy of how well systems throw exceptions and how well are these exceptions propagated with a distributed Web Services environment.



47 comments:

Ecare Technologies said...

Really a Nice Informative Post ,Keep it up.

giselle aga said...

Existing without the answers to the difficulties you’ve sorted out through this guide is a critical case, as well as the kind which could have badly affected my entire career if I had not discovered your website.
Java Training in Marathahalli

john kevin said...

Those guidelines additionally worked to become a good way to recognize that other people online have the identical fervor like mine to grasp great deal more around this condition.

oracle training in Bangalore

raina dhawan said...

I’m experiencing some small security issues with my latest blog, and
I’d like to find something safer. Do you have any suggestions?
dotnet training in marathahalli

sumathi s said...

I believe there are many more pleasurable opportunities ahead for individuals that looked at your site.safety institute in chennai

Swetha Gauri said...

Your good knowledge and kindness in playing with all the pieces were very useful. I don’t know what I would have done if I had not encountered such a step like this.
fire and safety courses in chennai

suvathi said...

I think this is the best article today. Thanks for taking your own time to discuss this topic, I feel happy about that curiosity has increased to learn more about this topic. Keep sharing your information regularly for my future reference.
Software Testing Training in Chennai

dhanusha said...

Well Said, you have furnished the right information that will be useful to anyone at all time. Thanks for sharing your Ideas.
Blue Prism Training in Chennai | Blue Prism Training in Velachery

Unknown said...

Really a Nice Informative Post ,Keep it up.thanks for publishing this post.
Web Designing Training Institute in Chennai | Web Designing Training Institute in Velachery

saraswathy r said...

This article is very useful to us.Thanks for posting this article.
Best Selenium Training Institute in Chennai | Best Selenium Training Insritute in Velachery

victoriya said...

Well Said, you have furnished the right information that will be useful to anyone at all time. Thanks for sharing your Ideas.
Certified Ethical Hacking Training Institute in Chennai | Certified Ethical Hacking Training Institute in Velachery

saraswathy r said...

Really nice blog...Keep updating..
VMWare Training Institute in Chennai | VMWare Training Institute in Velachery

ancy said...

Nice post

deepti said...

I read this article. I think You put a lot of effort to create this article. I appreciate your work.
CLOUD COMPUTING Classes in Chennai | CLOUD COMPUTING Courses in Velachery

ancy said...

Really a Nice Informative Post ,Keep it up.

VMWare Training Institute in Chennai | VMWare Training Institute in Velachery

rupiya rupi said...

This is very good information.Thanks for sharing.Automation Anywhere Training Institute in Chennai | Automation Anywhere Training Institute in Velachery

Saravanan said...

Good Post! you have furnished the right information that will be useful to anyone at all time. Thanks for sharing your Ideas.
Selenium Testing Course in Chennai | Selenium Testing Course in Velachery

ancy said...

Nice and informative article. Thanks for sharing such nice article, keep on updating.
Best Dotnet Training Institute in Chennai|Best Dotnet Training Institute in Velachery

revathi said...

Great post!The information provided is very useful..Thank you..
Software Testing Training Institute in Chennai|Software Testing Training Institute in Velachery

victoriya said...

This article is very nice to get information about the technology..Thanks..
Java Training Institute in Chennai|Java Training Institute in Velachery

krish said...

This blog is very informative..Thanks for the information you shared..
Python programming Training Institute in Chennai|
Python Programming Training Institute in Velachery

grace leah said...

Impressive blog with lovely information. Really very useful article for us thanks for sharing such a wonderful blog...
Best Android & IOS Training Institute in Chennai | Best Android & IOS Training Institute in Porur

harsha hai said...

Well Said, you have furnished the right information that will be useful to anyone at all time. Thanks for sharing your Ideas.
No.1 Automation Anywhere Training Institute in Chennai | No.1 Automation Anywhere Training Institute in Kanchipuram | No.1 Automation Anywhere Training Institute in Velachery

Vishal said...

You created an Impressive blog with lovely information.You made a really very useful article..Thanks for sharing such a wonderful blog...
VLSI Training Institute in Chennai|VLSI Training Institute in kanchipuram

adhi said...

This is the best article today. Thanks for taking your own time to discuss this topic. I felt happy while reading your article. Keep sharing your information regularly.
Dot Net Training Institute in Chennai|Dot Net Training Institute in Guindy

prabash said...

I feel really happy to have seen your webpage and look forward to so many more entertaining times reading here. Thanks once more for all the details.
No.1 Blue Prism Training Institute in Chennai | No.1 Blue Prism Training Institute in Velachery | No.1 Blue Prism Training Institute in Kanchipuram

deepti said...

Your article contains good information which is very useful for me.I liked your way of conveying this knowledge to enable this.Thanks for this wonderful article.Keep updating.
Web Designing Training Institute in Chennai|Web Designing Training Institute in Kanchipuram

Nisha Premrahul said...

I enjoy what you guys are usually up too. This sort of clever work and coverage! Keep up the wonderful works guys I’ve added you guys to my blogroll.
Automation Anywhere Training with Placement in Chennai | Automation Anywhere Training with Placement in Tambaram

rajendran said...

This is one of the best article today. Thanks for posting the information about the technology.I felt happy about that information you provided in this site.Keep sharing your information.Thanks Regards,
Cloud Computing Training Institute in Chennai|Cloud Computing Training Institute in Kanchipuram

Babyma said...

This is a Nice Information you posted in this article.This is very useful for me.Keep updating.Thanks.Regards,
Android and IOS Training Institute in Chennai|Android and IOS Training Institute in Tiruvallur

fawaz shaik said...

This is an interesting blog with lovely information.This is really very useful article for me.Thanks for sharing such a wonderful blog.Regards,
Java Training Institute in Chennai|Java Training Institute in Taramani


mekala said...

This is really a nice information you provided.Keep updating.Thanks for publishing this post.Regards,
CCNA Training Institute in Chennai|CCNA Training Institute in Saidapet

kalai hai said...

This information is very useful for me.Keep sharing your information.Thanks for posting the information about the technology.Regards,
Python Training Institute in Chennai|Python Training Institute in Kanchipuram

muthu said...

This blog is great.This information is very useful for me.Thanks for sharing your Ideas.Keep updating.Regards,
Robotics Training Institute in Chennai|Robotics Training Institute in OMR

bala kumar said...

I and my friends were going through the nice, helpful tips from the blog then the sudden came up with an awful suspicion I never expressed respect to the website owner for those secrets.
No.1 Automation Anywhere Training Institute in Chennai | No.1 Automation Anywhere Training Institute in Velachery

Anonymous said...

Good Post! Thank you so much for sharing this pretty post, it was so good to read and useful to improve my knowledge as updated one, keep blogging.

https://www.emexotechnologies.com/courses/other-technology-trainings/python-training/

https://www.emexotechnologies.com/courses/big-data-analytics-training/data-science-with-python-training/

https://www.emexotechnologies.com/courses/cloud-computing-training/amazon-web-services-aws-training/

https://www.emexotechnologies.com/courses/big-data-analytics-training/big-data-hadoop-training/

https://www.emexotechnologies.com/courses/other-technology-trainings/devops-training/

Anonymous said...

Good Post! Thank you so much for sharing this pretty post, it was so good to read and useful to improve my knowledge as updated one, keep blogging.

Python training in electronic city

Regu said...

Blogger Ad
----------
Good Post! Thank you so much for sharing this pretty post, it was so good to read and useful to improve my knowledge as updated one, keep blogging.

Python training in electronic city

data science with python training in electronic city

AWS training in electronic city

Big data hadoop training in electronic city

Devops training in electronic city

Selenium training in electronic

Java Training in electronic city

sanjay said...

Really you build a very good.I see your blog this is very nice and i gather lot of information in this blog.Thanks for sharing.keep sharing more blogs.
Advanced Ethical Hacking course in Chennai | Advanced Ethical Hacking course in Chennai

navya said...

Hello! This is my first visit to your blog! We are a team of volunteers and starting a new initiative in a community in the same niche. Your blog provided us useful information to work on. You have done an outstanding job.
SEO Training Institute in Chennai | SEO Training Institute in Kanchipuram

Saranya Karthik said...

Really it was an awesome article...very interesting to read.. You have provided a nice article....Thanks for sharing..
UIPath Robotic Process Automation in Chennai | UIPath Training in Tambaram

deepti said...

Very good and informative article. Thanks for sharing such nice article, keep on updating such good articles.
MCSE&MCSA Training institute in Chennai |MCSE&MCSA Training institute in Tambaram

teja said...

Thank you for taking the time to provide us with your valuable information. Keep sharing your post regularly..
No.1 Blue Prism Training Institute in Chennai | No.1 Blue Prism Training Institute in Kanchipuram

devo said...

Nice and informative article. Thanks for sharing such nice article, keep on updating.
Programming C, C++ Training Institute in Chennai|Programming C, C++ Training Institute in Kanchipuram

mallika said...

Awesome post. Really you are shared very informative concept... Thank you for sharing. Keep on updating...
Best Graphic designing& Multimedia courses in Chennai |Best Graphic designing& Multimedia courses in Guindy

devo said...

Nice post. Great information and really very much useful. Thanks for sharing and keep updating.
Best Selenium Training Institute in Chennai|Best Selenium Training Institute in Medavakkam

Saravanan said...

The strategy you posted was nice. The people who want to shift their career to the IT sector then it is the right option to go with the ethical hacking course.
Ethical Hacking Training in Chennai | Ethical Hacking Training in Shozhinganallur